Coming Out of the Christian Closet

I’m an English Major. Specifically a Creative Writing Concentration English Major. One of the biggest things I love about being an English Major is the community that I’m surrounded with as a result. In my experience, English majors are honest. They’re not narrow minded, and they’re not afraid to live outside the box.

Today, I got to go see the movie Blue Like Jazz with some English Majors, and I was reminded yet again of why I do life with these people. This post is the result of that movie, and the conversation that followed…

Truth Hurts

Honesty is something that you just can’t buy, and if you could, it wouldn’t be all that honest anymore anyway. I’m not talking about when someone just tells the truth, like when some mobster agrees to reveal the dirty secrets about his 2nd cousin Tony who is secretly The Godfather in a courtroom if they pay him enough to do it. I’m talking genuine, raw, vulnerable, messy, ugly, beautiful truth. The kind that comes out when your pastor isn’t around to hear you. The kind that you’re still convinced God is ashamed of you for. The kind that Jesus died on the cross for.

See, truth is not something someone says, or does, or writes, or draws. Truth goes deeper than that. For it to really be truth, it has to be life too. I think that’s why Jesus said He is not only the Truth, but the Life as well. Because dead truth isn’t enough. When something’s true, you know it not because it’s the right answer, but because you feel it. Something alive in the core of your being cries out and says “YES! That is alive! That’s real! I need that!” But there is a problem with this kind of truth…

Your demons always come right out of that prayer closet, wearing the embarrassing undies that you meant to throw away months ago.Truth, like the Man who is the Truth, always exposes darkness, anywhere it can be found. It’s a well trained watchdog that can smell the secrets rotting in your basement from a mile away. It leaves you with nothing to hide behind. It leaves you with nothing but you; the real you. I think sometimes Christians hide from Truth. I think the Church is terrified of it.

It’s not that we mean to lie, we’re just insecure. Just like almost every other person on the planet. We’re afraid of what others might think of us if we show them the “real me.” we are afraid of being rejected, or of being alone. Sometimes, loneliness feels worse than hell itself.

And it’s not like these fears came from nowhere either. You can remember exactly where they came from. That dad who was never there. That mom who could never love. That neighbor or realative who…you stop before the memory surfaces and you have to face it again. Wounds, buried and locked away behind stone walls in the depths of our heart. We pretend their healed, but warm blood still drips from the coffin. We embalm ourselves in religion, in being “biblical” or “walking by faith,” wearing Jesus’ smile on eyeless masks. We condemn the world for hiding behind sex, drugs, and loose living, but the world sees through our false faces, just like we do. Truth takes off these masks, unlocks the tomb, and we’re forced to face the tragedy of ourselves.

Truth Heals

But this isn’t the end of the story. Truth never stops there.

While films, poems, novels and art may only awaken the life that Truth carries, Truth Himself always takes us the rest of the way, if we let Him. While a poem like “Daddy” by Sylvia Plath may only take off the mask and expose the truth of abuse, the living pain we feel will drive us to the Man who died to heal that pain. Truth shows the ugly for how ugly it really is, but it thrives on what is beautiful.

The problem with religious systems and Christian masks isn’t that they prevent Jesus from healing us; He’s so good He’ll work behind them. The real problem is that when Jesus is doing all the work behind closed doors, all the world sees is the hypocrite in front of them. I know, because I’ve been that hypocrite.

There is one friend from High School that I will never forget. Her name is Kelly. Kelly was a few grades below me in high school, and far more popular than I could have hoped to be. She was a cheerleader, she was bubbling with personality, and she was absolutely beautiful (actually, she still is). My heart was drawn to her in a profound way, and I loved that girl for exactly who she was. Before you assume it was a crush, I’ll explain that while sometimes I did feel that attraction, it was mostly something far deeper and more familial than that. I think it was because God gave me eyes to see her a bit like He sees her. I could see not only who she was, but who she was made to be. I could see the Kelly she would become, and trust me friends, it is spectacular. She was not a Christian, and she had no good reason to want to be one. Her life was filled with heartache, abandonment, and pain I’d rather not talk about. However, she was still curious.

We would talk a lot about each of our beliefs, partially because I wasn’t very good at talking about anything else, and she was a good listener. She thought I was a bit out there, but at least she’d hear me out. I remember one conversation in particular. This is the one I desperately wish I could re-write.

We were sitting at dinner, talking about who Jesus really is. I was telling her that He wasn’t who she had made Him out to be, and that He loved her at a level she couldn’t even fathom. Then I said this:

“He really is the best thing that could ever happen to you. His love is more satisfying than anything this world has to offer.”

This is true, and now I can stand behind it even more than I could then, but I was lying when I said it. I remember looking into her eyes, my heart raw with Jesus’ heart for her, saying those words with tears in my eyes…all the while thinking in the back of my mind “I hope she doesn’t see that I don’t even know if this is true yet.” I wanted it to be true more than anything. My church said it was true, and the bible taught it to be true, but that was not my truth. As I talked about in my previous post, I was living hollow. I had never been satisfied like the satisfaction I was offering. I was still bleeding out under that mask. Although I had seen miracles, and I knew God existed, and I had genuinely felt His love, I was not healed enough to declare something so profound. To me, God was still the God of mostly enough; the God of “I love you, but I’ll never show you like you want Me to.” I was offering a Jesus I hoped to meet myself as if I already knew Him at that level. I was offering her my mask.

The hardest part is she took it. She came to an event at my church, and God genuinely touched her. She began a real relationship with Him that night, and I believe that she started that day was 100% legitimate, but she took my mask too. She gave her heart to Jesus, which brings me joy that I can’t put into words, but she also took my theology that I’d preached in the weeks before. She took my “more satisfying than anything” hook, line and sinker. She expected to experience that because I said it like it was what I’d experienced. Life kept hurting, and her faith didn’t live up to that expectation. She became quickly disillusioned, and our friendship began to fracture. Things became awkward between us and we stopped talking as much. I think I destroyed her trust in me. I haven’t had a conversation with her in nearly two years. Partially, because I’ve been to ashamed to admit that I failed her. I still wonder how things would have went if that conversation had gone more like this:

“Kelly, I’ll be honest with you… I still haven’t found total satisfaction. God hasn’t healed all my problems or made my life perfect. Sometimes, I wonder if He is really even the most important thing to me. I’m still broken, hurting, and confused, but I know He is real. I know that Jesus is the most loving Man I have ever met, and I know He will be gentile with your heart. He won’t force Himself on you, even though sometimes my abrasiveness may make it feel that way (I’m still working on that one). He’ll be kind to you, and He will heal everything you are willing to give Him. It won’t happen in your timing, and sometimes you’ll feel like He’s not even listening, but somehow you’ll always know He is. He won’t make everything all better all of the sudden, but he will make everything better than it could ever be without Him. Kelly, I still don’t have it all figured out, but I know 3 things: He is real, He is God, and He loves. Without this Man in your life, I promise you that something will be missing. God created you to know Him, and you’ll never be complete until you do.”

I’m not sure if that’s the best answer. I’m not even sure if it’s all theologically sound. But I am sure it is true. It has no mask, and it would let her see that while I’m still wounded, the Healer is at work. I could say that without thinking in the back of my head that I might be lying. I could say that and know what I’m saying isn’t a fairy tale or wishful thinking. I could know, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that I was pointing her towards the Way, the Truth and the Life. Because in the end, Truth is a Man, and to know that Man is the only thing I have found that’s worth living for.


And Kelly, If you’re reading this, I’m sorry. Know that I never meant to let you down, and that I was never being your friend just to convert you. You are incredible, and you are worth my time. I’m still here if you ever want to talk, and I miss you my friend.

8 thoughts on “Coming Out of the Christian Closet

  1. Karsten, “I was lying …” and “I felt like I was lying …” are two different things. The greatest, most satisfying moments in my life have God’s presence at their core. I’m not saying that I experience nothing but highs with God. That would be a lie. But to say nothing satisfies like God’s love and presence in my life would be the truth. Often I just don’t feel like it. Yet this is the distinction between living by faith and living by feeling. Even when I don’t feel like God is present or “the best thing to ever happen in my life,” I continue to set my life’s course based on the belief that I can trust God, I can believe His promises and the gift of life He offers me through His Son Jesus Christ.

    1. I hear what you’re saying Tom. I’ll rephrase and say “I was lying.” I do agree with you that God truly will be the most satisfying thing in my life. He has brought me more joy, clarity, and happiness than any other single thing I’ve ever known. However, I cannot yet say that he is “fully satisfying,” and I have not yet experienced him as the “most satisfying.” This last year I had a few experiences that I can say brought me closer than anything else ever has, but even still I’m not sure I can say he’s the “best thing in the world” in relation to my happiness with total honesty. However, because of what I have experienced, because of the relationship I do have with him, I am confident He will keep his word. I will one day be able to say those things I said to Kelly to someone else (or maybe even to her again) with complete sincerity, knowing in the core of my being that every word is true. I eagerly anticipate that day, and I’m confident it will come. Yet, until then, I think it’s dishonest to sell something I haven’t even tasted myself. I can sell family, I can sell community, I can sell the culture of the kingdom of heaven, I can sell God as healer and as Father and Friend. Those things I know, and will gladly herald as true. I can’t yet sell God as total satisfaction. I think as Christians, we have to be honest. I think to phrase something as if we’ve experienced it is hypocritical. It blinds people to who God really is because we are pretending to be at a place of intimacy we truly aren’t. The world needs something real, and the second we begin talking about something that isn’t yet real FOR OURSELVES, we stop making disciples and start just trying to make converts. Ya feel me? (My next post will actually be talking about this a bit. I think I’m calling it “The ‘Show Me’ God.” Stop by, I think You’ll enjoy it! 🙂 )

  2. Thank you so much for this post. I have been in the same position in the past. I have told people about how satisfying God is and not believing or seeing it myself, being completely unsatisfied. This is still a struggle for me but I do believe that the power of Christ and the Triune God can overcome even this. He knows how we struggle because Jesus was a man on earth who also struggled and saw it in everyone else, every day. And, He walks with us in our struggles. If I didn’t know this on a personal level, I wouldn’t be able to keep going day by day and keep believing. Thanks for being so honest and upfront, even if it is later rather than sooner.

    1. Ah, the humanity of Jesus. God and man. Truly something incredible which we can continually find hope in. Thanks for the read, and you can always count on the honesty here. 🙂

  3. Hi Karsten –

    I’m a big Don Miller fan also :).

    Your line struck me: “Sometimes, loneliness feels worse than hell itself.”

    True loneliness, for me, is when I’ve hidden myself away in rules and motives and ugly sterotypes….far away from God’s grace.

    Kinda like you said…hell. 🙂 Well put. Thanks for sharing!

    1. Yea, true. Unfortunately, sometimes either we’re not aware we’re doing that, or we don’t know how to do anything else. I’ve been in both of those situations. Heck, even God’s grace can become a cliche void of meaning if we divorce it from communion with God’s presence. (As I’m sure you know.) By the way, I took a look at your blog as well. I really enjoy your voice, and what you have to say. Glad you found me! 🙂

      1. I came here today to see if you had any new offerings, and I found one!

        I’m embarrassed to say I missed some of the message of this post….but I’m glad to say there’s always grace and I have the chance, still, to encourage you in your journey…

        Karsten, this was beautiful. Truly. I might have to finally figure out what this “reblog” thing is (if it means I’m directing my readers to your site).

        If I were not a Christian, after reading what you wrote, I think I’d be alot more inclined to consider believing in your God. I think what’s ugly about us Christians so much of the time is we sell something we’re not using ourselves.

        But here’s the thing – you did that (so easy to do) – and then you said, “That was wrong.” Humility is attractive to anyone…when I meet someone who’s humble, I’m always more inclined to consider what they’re saying (WHEN they’re speaking, ha!).

        You said, ” I still don’t have it all figured out, but I know 3 things: He is real, He is God, and He loves.” Powerful. I’d say you have plenty figured out – you’ve got the crux of it figured out, for you….

        So we pray, and we yearn and we ask Jesus to be our arms and legs and ask the Spirit for the words…and I think in Acts 4:32 we have a pretty great example….(not espousing communism, by the way – people like to get political with that)…just showing love the way people see it/feel it here. Once you know Jesus, you’ll never quite value those things (material needs) in the same manner, but if you don’t – of course you value them! It’s all you have to go on.

        I’m no expert, but I’d love to hear more from you and see you out there telling your stories in person someday. 🙂

      2. Thank you so much. Your words are very encouraging, and help confirm to me that I’m still pursuing the right path in my writings. I’ve always found humility funny, because when you get down to it, it’s really just being honest. I used to think it was impossibly hard to be humble, but authenticity? Anybody can do that. If I’m transparent enough, people will see Jesus standing behind me, you know?
        Honestly, for me it’s all about relationship. I can’t give away a message anymore. All I can do is be me, let Jesus be Jesus, and the two of us go and love people together. It’s simple and it’s worth it.
        You will keep hearing from me on here, and I expect that one day you just might hear me at some church or conference or something. I really appreciate your support. Thanks again.
        p.s. Click “reblog” in the upper left hand corner of the page when you are on the page you want to reblog. Should be pretty easy from there. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s